Posted on 4/15/2025 by Leanne Penny

The Best Places for Boat Rentals in New Buffalo

New Buffalo, Michigan, located on the shores of Lake Michigan, has a variety of boating experiences that cater to everyone from the novice sailor to the experienced yachtsman. 

Whether you're looking to captain your own vessel or prefer a guided tour with an experienced skipper, New Buffalo's marinas and boat rental services provide plenty of options to explore the stunning waters of Lake Michigan. 

If you're looking for the perfect base for your maritime adventures, Third Coast Vacations has over 25 vacation rentals in New Buffalo. Explore our properties and let us help you navigate your options for a thrilling Lake Michigan experience. 

In this article, we'll round up the best places for boat rentals in New Buffalo, dive into the diversity of rental types, navigate the best places to dock around town, and more.

Types of Boat Rentals

  • Drive Yourself: If you prefer the thrill of navigating your own course, self-drive boat rentals are available. These usually come in the form of smaller powerboats, best for cruising along the coastline or venturing into quieter river inlets. 
  • Captain Services: For a more relaxed experience, most places offer boats with captains. These skilled professionals can enhance your boating adventure with their local knowledge of the best sights and the richest fishing spots. 
  • Jet Skis: For the adrenaline seekers, jet ski rentals are a fast-paced way to enjoy the water and are typically available to rent by the hour. 
  • Pontoons: Best for groups looking to enjoy a leisurely day on the water, pontoon boats provide stability and space for gatherings, picnics, and swimming. 
  • Yacht Cruises: Those looking for a touch of luxury can choose yacht cruises, which are offered by several high-end charter services in the area. These vessels usually come with a variety of amenities and are perfect for celebrating special occasions.

Top Shops for Rentals

Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina

A staple in New Buffalo, Oselka Marina is known for its comprehensive boating services, including rentals ranging from hourly to daily options. This marina caters to boating enthusiasts with a variety of vessel types, including luxury yachts and functional jet skis, making sure you have a well-rounded experience with on-site fueling and provisioning available.

Knot Home Charters

Known for their tailored charter experiences, Knot Home Charters has a fleet of maintained and equipped boats perfect for family outings or romantic escapes. Their services include skilled captains who not only navigate but also share insights into the best local spots for sightseeing and relaxation on the water.

New Buffalo Sailing Excursions

New Buffalo Sailing Excursions is great if you're trying to go sailing. They offer lessons and excursions for both beginners and experienced sailors, providing a hands-on approach to navigating the waters of Lake Michigan with an emphasis on safety and fun.

Top Docking and Boating Spots in New Buffalo

New Buffalo Municipal Marina

A key feature of the local boating scene, New Buffalo Municipal Marina is a favorite among residents and visitors for its accessibility and close proximity to New Buffalo’s main attractions. It has plenty of docking space and is close to various recreational areas, perfect for those planning to explore Lake Michigan. Boaters are advised to secure a permit upon arrival or make a reservation in advance to ensure availability.

New Buffalo City Boat Launch

This public facility is designed for easy access to Lake Michigan, allowing boaters to launch their vessels smoothly. New Buffalo City Boat Launch is a convenient entry point for a day on the lake, with 24-hour access during the boating season. A small fee is charged for launching, making it a straightforward option for visitors and locals.

St. Joseph River Yacht Club

Not just a marina but a private community hub, the St. Joseph River Yacht Club has excellent facilities and a welcoming atmosphere for boaters. It’s a great spot for those looking to connect with other boating enthusiasts and enjoy a day on the river or the open lake.

Public vs. Private Boating Facilities

When planning your boating adventure in New Buffalo, you have the option to choose between public marinas and private yacht clubs. 

Facilities like New Buffalo Municipal Marina have open access to the general public for a small fee. These marinas provide essential services such as fuel, docking space, and sometimes rental services, making them great for casual outings and easy lake access. 

On the other hand, private yacht clubs offer exclusive services to their members. These clubs typically provide enhanced amenities, greater privacy, and host social and professional networking events. Membership fees apply, and access is generally restricted to club members and their guests.

Plan Your Next Adventure with Third Coast Vacations

New Buffalo is not just a prime summer destination; it's a perfect spot for year-round enjoyment thanks to its stunning Lake Michigan shoreline and vibrant boating culture. Whether you're interested in a serene sail, a fun family pontoon day, or a high-speed jet ski adventure, New Buffalo has the right rental for you. 

To make the most of your visit, consider staying with Third Coast Vacations. Our selection of local vacation homes gives you the perfect base for your waterfront escapades. 

Explore our properties and benefit from our team's insider tips to make sure your next visit to New Buffalo is seamless and memorable. Book now to lock in your stay!

Previous Family Friendly Ideas in the New Buffalo MI area Guide to New Buffalo and Top Southwest Michigan Farmers Markets Next

Categories