Whether you’re a returning guest with a favorite home or you’re planning your first trip to Harbor Country, this is the easiest way to find exactly what you’re looking for. Below, you’ll find a full list of our Lake Michigan beach rental homes by name, so if you already know the one you love, you can jump straight to it. With nearly 100 vacation rentals and airbnb Michigan stays across Southwest Michigan and Michigan city vacation rental homes, we make it easy to browse by property and book your stay with confidence. 

Lake Michigan Beach Rentals & Inland Retreats 

From lakefront homes in New Buffalo to charming cottages in Lakeside, our vacation rentals are handpicked for comfort, style, and location. Want to be close to the beach? Need space for a big group? Looking for a cozy couples' retreat or pet-friendly beach rentals? Our homes span the best destinations in Harbor Country, including Union Pier Michigan, Sawyer, Michiana rentals and beyond and include amenities like private hot tubs, fire pits, pools, EV chargers, and screened-in porches. We even have Lake Michigan rentals with private beaches and others with walkable beach access and luxury kitchens, perfect for soaking up the sun and entertaining or relaxing in style.

New Buffalo Beach Rentals for All Seasons

No matter the season, there's a perfect place waiting for you. Summer brings beach days and bonfires, fall is ideal for winery tours and hikes through the dunes, and winter is peaceful and cozy in one of our fire-lit retreats. Every home is professionally managed and maintained by our local team, so you can expect clean spaces, thoughtful touches, and local support if you need anything during your stay. Start your search below to find your favorite rental by name, and get ready to experience the best of Southwest Michigan and Northwest Indiana.