Lake Michigan Stays with Secluded Beach Access
101 properties available
Welcome to The Whittaker Suites in downtown New Buffalo! Third Coast Vacations presents this in conjunction with Toni Stays Collection. This beautifully decorated, coastal-themed unit is perfectly situated within walking distance of the town's charming shops and delicious restaurants. This is a second story unit and there is a flight of stairs to
Whittaker Suites 2B
Condo
$150 - $725 / per night
2
bedrooms
1
baths
4
guests
5
(33)
Welcome to The Crooked Lighthouse!Tucked into a quiet dead-end street in Union Pier, you will find The Crooked Lighthouse. Built in 2025, this 3-bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home has two king suites and a fun bunk room. There is a front porch, two private backyard decks and a 500 sq. ft. 4-season room. Plenty of room for everyone to spread out. It is though
The Crooked Lighthouse
House
$225 - $798 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
8
guests
5
(12)
Ash Harbor House is a stunning family getaway located just a half-mile walk from multiple private Association beaches. Newly built and professionally decorated, the home offers a haven of comfort and luxury for your entire group.Dark oak floors span the spacious, open main floor, where cathedral ceilings enhance the sense of space and a large smart
Ash Harbor House
House
$260 - $1,065 / per night
5
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
11
guests
5
(15)
Welcome to Vista Azul, a newer luxury retreat in the Harbor Shores community of St. Joseph. High ceilings, rustic hardwood floors, and stylish furnishings throughout give this home effortless comfort and charm, with a front porch offering partial marina and Harbor Village views and access to the community pool just across the street (open seasonall
Vista Azul
House
$220 - $814 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
1
half bath
8
guests
5
(7)
Welcome to Hygge House in Lakeside, a cozy, beautifully renovated retreat just 1,000 feet from a private Lake Michigan beach. Named for the Danish word meaning “coziness and contentment,” this two-bedroom, two-bath home was designed for rest, connection, and comfort in every season. With a spacious backyard, inviting fire pit, and thoughtfully styl
Hygge House
House
$150 - $639 / per night
2
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(33)
Welcome to La Dolce Vita, another great home offered by Third Coast Vacations, a full-service vacation rental company run by locals who love Harbor Country.When you book with us, you’re not just getting another vacation rental—you’re getting access to the area’s experts. We know where to go because we live here, and we love it.Third Coast Vacations
La Dolce Vita
House
$196 - $1,226 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
12
guests
5
(50)
Welcome to Take It Easy, a rare waterfront Beachwalk Resort home located directly on Lake Kai with its own private sandy beach, hot tub, and three levels of light-filled living space. One of only a handful of homes in the community with true waterfront access, this beautifully updated retreat offers stunning lake views and immediate access to Beach
Take It Easy
House
$259 - $1,909 / per night
5
bedrooms
4
baths
17
guests
5
(2)
Lake Michigan, a heated pool, a hot tub, and five bedrooms—this is the New Buffalo getaway you've been looking for!Welcome to this spacious five-bedroom retreat in the sought-after Sunset Shores neighborhood of New Buffalo. Lake Michigan is just steps away, with the home located only one house from a neighborhood beach access. Spend your days walki
Shore Gathers
House
$375 - $1,528 / per night
5
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
Please Note: Pool Availability: Guests can not use the pool after 2 pm on Friday until 5 PM on Sunday.Welcome to It's a Wonderful Life, a contemporary Union Pier retreat where Lake Michigan days and relaxing evenings come naturally. Built in 2021, this spacious four-bedroom, three-bath home features an open-concept design, a private hot tub, a fi
It's a Wonderful Life
House
$220 - $1,121 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
5
(4)
Just steps from the HOA pool and walkable to all the charm of downtown New Buffalo, Taylor Street Retreat is a newly updated getaway built for lake town living. With space for up to 12 guests across four bedrooms this home is the perfect home base for your Harbor Country Vacation. Spend sunny afternoons on the screen porch, gather around the firepi
Taylor Street Retreat
House
$243 - $1,782 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
13
guests
5
(10)
Lake Front with a sandy beach, private 87 degree pool, Private hot tub and Private gym. The exterior features an expansive lake front, multi-level deck that includes an 8 person hot-tub, chaises with umbrellas, two comfy outdoor Restoration Hardware couches, a gas firepit, a gas grill and massive round dining table plus 50 steps down to the sand. M
Michiana Beach House
House
$2,400 - $4,500 / per night
6
bedrooms
6
baths
1
half bath
15
guests
THE POOL IS OPENING FOR MAY 1, 2026!!Located in a cul-de-sac near Forest Beach in New Buffalo Township and built in 2021, featuring new furnishings, beds, TVs, appliances, and so much more! Enjoy a refreshing dip in the heated pool, or treat your muscles to a relaxing time in the brand new hot tub.The main living space is located on the second floo
New Buffalo Getaway Chalet
House
$270 - $1,435 / per night
5
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
11
guests
4.9
(16)
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Third Coast Vacations
All Rights Reserved.