Owner Statement page
101 properties available
Escape to this bright and welcoming downtown New Buffalo cottage, just a five-minute walk to shops, restaurants, and the beach. Lake Escape sleeps up to 8 guests across 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, and 5 beds in the main house — plus a private guest house with its own queen bed, full bath, and pull-out sleeper sofa for extra flexibility.Step inside to a br
Lake Escape
House
$180 - $726 / per night
3
bedrooms
3
baths
8
guests
5
(40)
Welcome to La Luna Lakefront on Lake Michigan, a dreamy, artfully styled escape where lake breezes, moonlit nights, and sand-between-your-toes living are included. With four spacious suites, beautiful details, and wide-open common spaces built for gathering, this home is all about laid-back luxury. Whether you're gazing at the beach over a cup of c
La Luna Lakefront
House
$400 - $3,336 / per night
6
bedrooms
6
baths
1
half bath
12
guests
5
(13)
Lake Michigan, a heated pool, a hot tub, and five bedrooms—this is the New Buffalo getaway you've been looking for!Welcome to this spacious five-bedroom retreat in the sought-after Sunset Shores neighborhood of New Buffalo. Lake Michigan is just steps away, with the home located only one house from a neighborhood beach access. Spend your days walki
Shore Gathers
House
$375 - $1,431 / per night
5
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
Welcome to Hygge House in Lakeside, a cozy, beautifully renovated retreat just 1,000 feet from a private Lake Michigan beach. Named for the Danish word meaning “coziness and contentment,” this two-bedroom, two-bath home was designed for rest, connection, and comfort in every season. With a spacious backyard, inviting fire pit, and thoughtfully styl
Hygge House
House
$150 - $653 / per night
2
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(33)
Welcome to Elegant Ease, a beautiful cottage in Merchant Street Cottages, offered by Third Coast Vacations, a full-service vacation rental company run by locals who love Harbor Country.When you book with us, you aren’t just getting another vacation rental company, you’re getting access to the area’s experts. We know where to go because we live here
Elegant Ease
House
$300 - $1,724 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
10
guests
5
(31)
Welcome to Pine Lake Lookout, a charming Pine Lake home offered by Third Coast Vacations, a full-service vacation rental company run by locals who love the area.We’re not just another Vacation Rental Company, booking with us gets you access to the area’s experts. We know where to go because we live here and we love it. Staying with us gets you: Di
Pine Lake Lookout
House
$200 - $1,034 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
12
guests
5
(6)
This beautifully designed 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a luxurious escape in the heart of Harbor Country. Nestled on a lush, wooded lot with a private pond, hydrangea-lined gardens, and elegant outdoor spaces, Four Seasons is made for relaxation. Inside, enjoy an open-concept layout, modern furnishings, and three serene bedrooms—each with its own
Four Seasons Retreat
House
$250 - $883 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(18)
Welcome to The Whittaker Suites in downtown New Buffalo! This beautifully decorated, coastal-themed unit is perfectly situated within walking distance of the town's charming shops and delicious restaurants.Want to check out the beach? Just walk out the door to Whittaker Street and you can see Lake Michigan! The New Buffalo Public Beach is just a fu
Whittaker Suites 1A
Condo
$150 - $769 / per night
2
bedrooms
2
baths
4
guests
5
(56)
Welcome to Crowe’s Cottage - Located in the coveted Sturgeon Beach community, Crowe’s Cottage is a charming 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home that offers guests a taste of laid-back lake life. Just two blocks from HOA Lake Michigan beachfront, this home offers the perfect balance of comfort, location, and family-friendly amenities. With space for up to 10
Crowes Cottage
House
$284 - $1,166 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
5
(3)
Lake Front with a sandy beach, private 87 degree pool, Private hot tub and Private gym. The exterior features an expansive lake front, multi-level deck that includes an 8 person hot-tub, chaises with umbrellas, two comfy outdoor Restoration Hardware couches, a gas firepit, a gas grill and massive round dining table plus 50 steps down to the sand. M
Michiana Beach House
House
$2,400 - $4,500 / per night
6
bedrooms
6
baths
1
half bath
18
guests
Welcome to Susie’s Getaway, a charming lakeshore cottage offered by Third Coast Vacations, a full-service vacation rental company run by locals who love Harbor Country. When you book with us, you aren’t just getting another vacation rental company, you’re getting access to the area’s experts. We know where to go because we live here and we love it
Susie's Getaway
House
$150 - $809 / per night
2
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
4.9
(26)
Welcome to Harbor Breeze Cottage—a gorgeous New Buffalo getaway in Merchant St Cottages designed for families and friends to gather, relax, and make lasting memories. This professionally decorated home combines luxury touches with cozy comfort, featuring multiple gathering spaces, a private hot tub, and a prime location just steps from the communit
Harbor Breeze Cottage
House
$413 - $1,640 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
1
half bath
14
guests
5
(8)
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Third Coast Vacations
All Rights Reserved.